Johnny’s New York Style Pizza in Atlanta: What to Know Before You Go

If you live in Atlanta or you’re visiting and craving classic, foldable New York–style slices in a casual setting, Johnny’s New York Style Pizza is one of the names you’ll see again and again. It’s a local-friendly, comfort-food spot that mixes neighborhood pizzeria vibes with a menu broad enough to feed a whole group.

This guide walks through how Johnny’s typically works in and around Atlanta—what to expect with the food, atmosphere, prices, locations, and practical tips for locals and visitors.

What Is Johnny’s New York Style Pizza?

Johnny’s New York Style Pizza is a casual dining pizza restaurant known for:

• Thin, foldable New York–style crust
• A mix of whole pies and large slices
• A full menu of comfort food: pastas, subs, wings, and salads
• Neighborhood-style dining where you can bring kids, friends, or coworkers

Most locations around Atlanta lean more relaxed and family-friendly than trendy. Think TV screens with the game on, red-check table vibes in some spots, and a go-to place for pizza nights, youth sports teams, and low-key group dinners.

Where You’ll Find Johnny’s Around Atlanta

Johnny’s has multiple locations in and around Metro Atlanta, often in busy neighborhood shopping centers or near major commuter routes. You’ll commonly see it in areas like:

• Intown & ITP-adjacent areas such as Decatur and nearby suburbs
• North Atlanta suburbs like Roswell, Alpharetta, and Cumming
• East & West corridor suburbs off I-20 and other main roads

Each location is individually operated, so floor plans, décor, and bar setups can vary, but the core menu and general experience are usually similar.

If you’re trying to decide which Atlanta-area Johnny’s to visit, consider:

• Proximity to home, hotel, or office
• Parking availability (most locations have surface lots)
• Whether you want table service, a sports-bar feel, or a quieter dine-in

Atmosphere: Casual, Kid-Friendly, and Game-Night Ready

Most Johnny’s locations in and around Atlanta fit squarely in “casual dining / comfort food” territory:

• Dress code: Very relaxed—athleisure, jeans, or team gear is the norm.
• Noise level: Can be fairly lively at dinner or on game days; slower times are usually quieter.
• Families: Children are common, especially early evenings and weekends.
• Sports viewing: Many locations have TVs with major games on, especially Falcons, Braves, Hawks, United, and college football.

If you’re planning:

• A family dinner: Early evening is usually easier with kids, and you’ll often see other families.
• A game watch with friends: Aim for weekend afternoons or prime-time game hours.
• A quieter meal: Consider weekday lunches or late lunch/early dinner gaps.

What’s on the Menu at Johnny’s (Atlanta Perspective)

Although menus can vary a bit by location, you’ll generally find a broad, comfort-focused lineup.

Classic New York–Style Pizza

You can expect:

• Thin, hand-tossed crust with a foldable slice
• Red sauce and mozzarella base on most pies
• Cheese, pepperoni, and veggie standards
• Specialty pizzas that often include:
  • Meat-heavy pies (sausage, pepperoni, bacon)
  • White pizzas with garlic and ricotta
  • Supreme/“all the toppings” options

💡 Atlanta tip: Order a large pizza if you’re feeding a group—it’s typically more cost-effective than multiple smalls, and leftover slices are easy to reheat (especially if you’re staying in an Airbnb or extended-stay hotel).

Slices vs. Whole Pies

Many Atlanta-area Johnny’s locations offer:

• Whole pies: custom toppings and specialty combos
• By-the-slice options: often limited to cheese, pepperoni, and a couple of rotating specials

Slices are especially popular for:

• Downtown/near-office lunch crowds
• Solo diners or quick grabs on the way home

Appetizers and Sides

You’ll typically see familiar comfort-food starters, such as:

• Garlic knots or bread sticks
• Wings (traditional or boneless, multiple sauces)
• Mozzarella sticks or cheesy bread
• Side salads

These can be practical if you’re splitting multiple things among a group and want to stretch the table without overspending on mains.

Pastas, Subs, and More

Johnny’s is not just pizza. Most locations in Metro Atlanta also serve:

• Baked pastas (lasagna-style dishes, baked ziti, etc.)
• Hot subs (meatball, Italian, chicken parmesan)
• Cold subs, depending on location
• Large entrée salads, often customizable with extra proteins

This makes Johnny’s workable when not everyone in your group wants pizza, or you’re looking for something a bit heavier or lighter than a slice.

Kid-Friendly Options

Johnny’s generally works well for kids because of:

• Plain cheese or simple topping pizzas
• Familiar sides like fries or garlic bread
• Ability to share a big pie instead of ordering multiple kids’ meals

Some locations may have a kids’ menu or smaller-portion options, but even where they don’t, families often just share a large pizza and add a salad or appetizer.

Dining Options: Dine-In, Takeout, and Delivery

In Atlanta, Johnny’s typically feels very flexible depending on how you want to eat.

Dine-In

Many locations offer:

• Full-service or partial-service dining rooms
• Beer and sometimes wine or basic cocktails (varies by location and local rules)
• TVs with sports and casual hangout vibes

Dine-in is common for:

• Post-game youth sports teams
• Office lunches
• Neighborhood pizza nights

Takeout

Takeout is one of the most common ways Atlantans use Johnny’s:

• Call-ahead or online ordering is usually available.
• Pizzas are boxed for easy pickup and transport.
• You’ll often find curbside or reserved parking spots near the door at some strip center locations.

Tip for locals in traffic-heavy areas:

• Place your order before you get on 400, 75/85, or 285 and time your pickup for when you reach your exit. It can save time versus waiting to order once you’re off the highway.

Delivery

Delivery availability can depend on:

• Your exact address in Atlanta or the suburbs
• Whether a particular Johnny’s location works with third-party delivery platforms
• The store’s own delivery radius

If you’re staying at a hotel near Perimeter, Cumberland, or other major business districts, there is often at least one Johnny’s within typical delivery range, though you’ll need to confirm based on your hotel’s address.

Pricing and Budgeting for a Meal at Johnny’s

While prices vary by location and size of your order, Johnny’s usually sits in the mid-range for casual pizza in Atlanta:

• Slices: Generally an affordable quick lunch or solo snack
• Whole pies: More economical when feeding several people
• Add-ons (extra toppings, wings, salads): Can add up, so plan your order if you’re on a budget

Simple Budget Snapshot (Typical Patterns)

To manage costs:

• Stick to 1–2 toppings rather than many individual extras.
• Share one appetizer instead of multiple.
• Use water or soft drinks if you’re watching the bill, as alcohol will raise the total quickly at any casual dining spot.

When to Go: Timing, Crowds, and Parking

Busiest Times in Atlanta

Based on typical Atlanta dining patterns, Johnny’s can be busy during:

• Friday and Saturday evenings (family and group dinners)
• Game days, especially major football or playoff games
• Weekday lunch in work-heavy corridors (Perimeter, Cumberland, Roswell/Alpharetta business parks)

If you want to avoid crowds, consider:

• Weekday afternoons between lunch and dinner
• Later dinners on weeknights
• Takeout timed outside peak rush (6–8 p.m.)

Parking

Most Johnny’s locations in Metro Atlanta are in strip centers or standalone buildings, usually with:

• Free surface parking
• Spots shared with other businesses

In denser intown areas, parking can be a bit tighter during peak hours, so allow a few extra minutes to circle the lot or park slightly farther away.

Dietary Considerations and Customization

While Johnny’s is a comfort-food-focused spot—heavy on cheese, dough, and classic toppings—many locations allow for some basic customization that can help if you have preferences or restrictions:

• Topping choice: You can build-your-own pizza to avoid or include specific meats and veggies.
• Cheese amounts: Some kitchens will accommodate lighter cheese or extra cheese requests.
• Simple salads: Useful if someone in your group wants a lighter or veggie-forward option.

If you have strict dietary needs or allergies, it’s wise to:

• Call the specific Atlanta location ahead of time.
• Ask what they can realistically do in that kitchen.

Keep in mind that pizzerias usually have flour and dairy throughout the workspace, so complete separation from common allergens is often not guaranteed.

Ordering Tips for Atlanta Locals and Visitors

A few practical ways to make Johnny’s work well for you around Atlanta:

• For long drives home: Order well-done or ask for a slightly crisper crust so it holds up better in the box during a commute.
• For hotel stays: Go with simple toppings (cheese, pepperoni, veggie) that reheat well in a microwave or toaster oven, if available.
• For kids’ birthday gatherings: Large pizzas plus a couple of appetizers are usually easier to manage than multiple custom orders.
• For office lunches: Order several large pies with a mix of cheese, pepperoni, veggie, and one “adventurous” specialty to cover different tastes.

How Johnny’s Fits into Atlanta’s Restaurant Landscape

In the Atlanta dining scene, Johnny’s typically fills a specific niche:

• More relaxed and “neighborhood” than upscale pizza restaurants
• More dine-in–focused than a grab-and-go slice-only shop
• A familiar, repeatable option for people who live or work nearby

If you’re new to Atlanta or just visiting, Johnny’s can be a reliable baseline:

• You know you’ll get classic New York–style pizza
• You can bring a mixed group (kids, coworkers, friends) without worrying much about dress codes or formality
• You can usually choose between dine-in, takeout, or delivery, depending on your schedule

For locals, it tends to be the kind of place you rotate into your routine when you want something easy, filling, and familiar—especially in the suburbs and commuter corridors.