Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop in Atlanta: What to Know Before You Go

If you’re in Atlanta, Georgia and craving classic Southern desserts, Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop is one of the spots locals and visitors often look for. While the brand is known across the Southeast, what matters most when you’re in Atlanta is: Where can you get it? What should you order? And how does it fit into the city’s food scene—especially under “International Cuisine” and restaurants?

This guide breaks that down from an Atlanta-focused angle so you know what to expect, how to plan a visit, and what options you have if you’re exploring pies around the metro area.

Where Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Fits Into Atlanta’s Food Scene

Atlanta’s restaurant scene is packed with global and regional flavors—from Buford Highway’s international strip malls to Southern comfort food on the Westside. Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop sits in the Southern dessert lane, with a focus on:

• Scratch-made pies
• Nostalgic, Southern-inspired flavors
• Small, shareable sizes as well as full pies

On many city guides, you’ll see it categorized under “International Cuisine” simply because it brings a distinct, regional-American style of baking that contrasts with everyday chain desserts and reflects Southern culinary heritage, which draws visitors from all over the world.

So if you’re planning where to eat in Atlanta and want something that feels authentically Southern after trying Korean BBQ, Ethiopian, Mexican, or Indian along Buford Highway or Midtown, Buttermilk Sky Pie is often on the radar as a dessert stop.

Finding Buttermilk Sky Pie in and Around Atlanta

Because individual shop locations and hours can change over time, it’s always a good idea to confirm the nearest Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop before heading out. When looking from an Atlanta perspective, people typically:

• Check options inside the Perimeter (I-285) first for convenience
• Consider northern suburbs (like Cobb, Gwinnett, or North Fulton) if they’re already traveling that way
• Look for Buttermilk Sky when planning shopping trips, since shops are often near busy retail or mixed-use areas

If you’re staying in popular areas like Downtown, Midtown, Buckhead, or near Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport, plan for:

• A short drive or rideshare to reach a shop, depending on current locations
• Factoring Atlanta traffic patterns, especially weekday rush hours (roughly 7–9 a.m. and 4–7 p.m.)

📝 Tip: When searching maps or delivery apps, use “Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop” + “Atlanta” or near your ZIP code. The metro area is large; some locations that show up as “Atlanta area” may technically be in nearby cities or suburbs but still practical to reach.

What to Expect on the Menu

While exact offerings can vary by location and season, Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop typically focuses on a core menu of pies with rotating flavors. In the Atlanta area, you can generally expect:

Classic Southern-Style Pies

Common flavors you’re likely to see include:

• Buttermilk – A traditional Southern custard-style pie with a tangy-sweet filling
• Pecan – Sweet, rich, and nutty, a staple across the South
• Coconut or coconut cream – Often topped with toasted coconut
• Chocolate or chocolate cream – Smooth, rich filling and flaky crust
• Key lime or citrus-based – Tart and refreshing, especially popular in warm weather
• Apple or fruit pies – Varying by season, often with a crumb or lattice topping

Many Atlanta locals appreciate that these pies feel homemade rather than overly processed, which fits the city’s growing interest in small-batch, bakery-style desserts.

Pie Sizes and Portions

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shops often offer:

• Full-size pies – Ideal for family dinners, office events, or parties
• Mini pies – Helpful if you:
  • Want to sample multiple flavors
  • Need individual portions for events
  • Prefer not to commit to a full pie

For someone living in Atlanta with frequent gatherings—tailgates, watch parties, church events, office meetings—having multiple minis in different flavors is a common strategy.

Dine-In, Takeout, and Delivery Options in Atlanta

How you enjoy Buttermilk Sky Pie in Atlanta depends on your schedule and where you are in the city.

Quick Visit or Takeout

If you’re already out exploring neighborhoods—say shopping in Buckhead, hitting the BeltLine, or visiting Midtown:

• You can usually walk in, choose from the display case, and take pies to go.
• It’s smart to call ahead if you need:
  • Multiple full pies
  • Specific flavors
  • Holiday or weekend orders, which can sell out faster

Because Atlanta traffic can be unpredictable, locals often pair a pickup stop with other errands in the same area.

Delivery and Third-Party Apps

In many parts of metro Atlanta, dessert shops like Buttermilk Sky Pie may be available through third‑party delivery services. Availability depends on:

• Your ZIP code
• Distance from the nearest shop
• Peak delivery times (evenings and weekends are busier)

For visitors staying at Downtown hotels, Midtown, or around Perimeter Center, delivery can be a convenient way to try the pies without navigating unfamiliar roads or MARTA connections.

🧁 Pro tip for busy Atlantans: For office meetings in central business districts like Downtown, Midtown, or Cumberland/Galleria, consider scheduling delivery to arrive before the meeting start time to allow for setup.

Ordering Ahead for Events and Holidays

Atlanta has a strong culture of gatherings and celebrations—from college football weekends to family reunions and church events. Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop often becomes part of:

• Thanksgiving and Christmas desserts
• Easter lunches
• Graduation celebrations
• Office parties and retirements

When to Order Ahead

In the Atlanta area, it’s especially important to order ahead if:

• It’s close to a major holiday
• You need more than one full pie
• You want a specific flavor in a specific size
• You’re coordinating with other dishes and want to avoid last‑minute stress

A common pattern among Atlantans is to place pie orders several days in advance for big holidays and at least 24–48 hours for larger office or family gatherings, depending on the shop’s policy.

Questions to Ask When You Call

When you contact a Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop near Atlanta, it’s helpful to ask:

• What flavors are available on my date?
• Do you offer mini pies, full pies, or both for this flavor?
• What is the cutoff time for same-day or next-day orders?
• How should I store the pie until serving? (Room temperature vs. refrigerated)

This helps you plan around Atlanta’s warm, humid climate, especially for cream-based or chocolate pies if you’re transporting them across town.

How Buttermilk Sky Compares to Other Atlanta Dessert Options

Atlanta offers a wide variety of dessert and bakery experiences, so understanding where Buttermilk Sky fits can help you decide if it matches what you’re looking for.

Position in the Atlanta Dessert Landscape

In broad terms, your main choices in the city include:

• Traditional Southern bakeries (cakes, pies, cobblers)
• International bakeries (Latin American, Asian, European-style pastries)
• Ice cream and gelato shops
• Boutique dessert bars and cafes

Buttermilk Sky is usually a match if you:

• Want a classic, Southern-style pie with familiar flavors
• Prefer simple, nostalgic desserts over highly decorated cakes
• Need something that suits a mix of tastes and ages—from kids to grandparents

By contrast, if you’re looking for highly experimental or fusion desserts or specifically non-Western sweets, you might explore other shops on Buford Highway, in Doraville, Chamblee, or around Duluth, then pair that experience with traditional pies from a place like Buttermilk Sky on another day.

Rough Planning Guide for an Atlanta Visit Including Pie

If you’re visiting Atlanta and want to fold Buttermilk Sky Pie into your plans, this simple planning structure can help you visualize your day:

This approach minimizes backtracking in traffic and makes dessert planning feel more intentional instead of rushed.

Practical Tips for Atlantans and Visitors

To make the most of a stop at Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop in or around Atlanta:

• Check the nearest location and hours before you go. Metro Atlanta is large, and not every dessert shop is right around the corner.
• Consider traffic. If you’re picking up pies before an event, add extra drive time, especially if crossing I‑75, I‑85, or I‑285 during rush hour.
• Order ahead for groups. For 8+ people, full pies or multiple minis are usually more practical than hoping to find enough in the case at peak times.
• Plan for storage. If you’ll be out in the heat or walking around the city, think about when you can get the pies to a cool, indoor space.
• Ask about serving suggestions. Some pies may taste best slightly warmed; others are meant to be served chilled, which matters if you’re coordinating with other dishes.

When Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Is a Good Fit for You in Atlanta

You’re likely to enjoy adding Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop to your Atlanta food plans if you:

• Appreciate traditional Southern desserts
• Want a reliable, pie-focused shop rather than a general bakery
• Need an easy, crowd-pleasing option for family events, office gatherings, or holidays
• Are exploring the “Southern” side of Atlanta’s broader, international food culture and want a dessert that reflects that identity

Whether you’re a long-time Atlantan or just in town for a weekend, knowing how and where to work a Buttermilk Sky pie into your schedule can help you enjoy one of the South’s most comforting desserts without added stress.