Johnny’s New York Style Pizza in Atlanta: What to Know Before You Go

Johnny’s New York Style Pizza is a familiar name across metro Atlanta, especially if you’re craving thin-crust, foldable New York–style slices without leaving Georgia. Whether you live in-town, commute from the suburbs, or are visiting Atlanta and want a casual pizza night, Johnny’s can be an easy, predictable option.

This guide walks through how Johnny’s works in and around Atlanta—from what’s on the menu and which neighborhoods have locations, to tips for ordering, parking, delivery, and things families and groups might care about.

What Makes Johnny’s New York Style Pizza “New York Style”?

If you’re in Atlanta and hearing “New York style,” you can generally expect:

• Large, thin slices with a crisp bottom and chewy edge
• Simple toppings like cheese, pepperoni, sausage, and veggies, plus specialty pies
• Hand-tossed dough baked directly on the stone or deck
• A pizza that’s easy to fold in half and eat on the go

Johnny’s leans into this classic style while still feeling like a neighborhood pizza place. Many Atlanta-area locations also serve:

• Calzones and stromboli
• Pastas (like baked ziti, spaghetti with meatballs)
• Subs and sandwiches
• Salads and appetizers (garlic knots, wings, etc.)

If you’re used to Atlanta’s other popular pizza spots that serve thicker crusts or Neapolitan-style pies, Johnny’s will feel more like a pizzeria you’d find in the Northeast—adapted for local tastes.

Where You’ll Find Johnny’s in the Atlanta Area

Johnny’s New York Style Pizza is not just one restaurant—it’s a chain with multiple locations around metro Atlanta and the rest of Georgia. Exact locations can change over time, but Atlantans commonly find Johnny’s in and around:

• Intown & ITP (Inside the Perimeter)

  • Neighborhoods like Decatur, Virginia-Highland, or nearby eastside and northside communities may have relatively close access, depending on the year and openings/closings.

• North Metro Atlanta

  • You’re more likely to see Johnny’s around Alpharetta, Roswell, Johns Creek, Cumming, Suwanee, and Woodstock.
  • These suburban locations are popular with families and youth sports teams.

• Other Metro Suburbs

  • Additional outposts often appear around Gwinnett County, Cobb County, and Cherokee County.

Because locations can shift, the most reliable way to find the nearest Atlanta-area Johnny’s is to:

1. Use a map app and search “Johnny’s New York Style Pizza Atlanta.”
2. Check hours, parking notes, and recent reviews for the specific store you plan to visit.

If you’re staying in areas like Downtown Atlanta, Midtown, or Buckhead, you may need a short drive or delivery from a nearby suburb if there isn’t a convenient in-town location at the moment.

Typical Menu Highlights at Johnny’s (Atlanta Locations)

While menus can vary slightly by franchise, most Atlanta Johnny’s locations include:

Classic New York–Style Pizzas

• Cheese – Thin crust, tomato sauce, mozzarella.
• Pepperoni – A go-to for most families and office orders.
• Meat Lovers / Deluxe – Multiple meats like pepperoni, sausage, bacon, and ham.
• Veggie – Peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives, and other vegetables.
• Specialty pies – Often include combinations like white pizza, BBQ chicken, or Greek-inspired toppings.

Sizes usually include:

• Slices (often available for lunch)
• Medium and large pies (good for families or sharing)
• In some locations, XL pies for big groups or watch parties

Beyond Pizza

Most Atlanta-area Johnny’s also offer:

• Calzones & stromboli – Stuffed with cheese and your choice of toppings.
• Wings – Often with a range of sauces from mild to spicy.
• Subs and hoagies – Italian, meatball, chicken parm, or cold cuts.
• Salads – Garden, Greek, Caesar; sometimes served in side or large sizes.
• Pasta dishes – Baked pastas, spaghetti, and similar comfort-food options.

If you have dietary needs, you can ask the specific location about:

• Gluten-sensitive crust options
• Cheese-free or light-cheese pizzas
• Ingredient details for allergies (e.g., dairy, nuts, or gluten in sauces and dough)

Because recipes and options can differ slightly, it’s wise to call the specific Atlanta Johnny’s you’ll be visiting or check their posted menu before going if you have strict dietary requirements.

Price Expectations for an Atlanta Visit

Prices vary across metro Atlanta, but many people find Johnny’s sits in the mid-range for pizza:

• Slices – Typically affordable for a quick lunch or snack.
• Whole pies – Cost depends on size and toppings, but usually comparable to other sit-down or delivery pizzerias.
• Combos – Some locations offer lunch specials that combine a slice or small pizza with a drink or salad.

For budgeting a family meal in Atlanta:

*Exact prices depend on location, size, and toppings; check menus or call ahead for current details.

For office lunches or team gatherings in Atlanta, large pizzas and tray-style salads can be cost-effective compared with individual boxed lunches.

Eating at Johnny’s vs. Delivery or Takeout

In metro Atlanta, your Johnny’s experience can look different depending on how you order.

Dine-In

Common features at many Atlanta-area Johnny’s:

• Casual, family-friendly dining rooms
• TVs often showing sports, which makes it a common pick for game days
• A mix of booths and tables, sometimes bar seating

This can work well if you’re:

• Bringing kids after school or sports
• Meeting friends before or after an Atlanta United, Hawks, or Braves game (at a location near your route)
• Wanting a relaxed, no-fuss dinner without cooking

Takeout

Takeout is popular with Atlanta residents who want to:

• Bring pizza home after commuting through traffic
• Grab food on the way to a gathering, watch party, or park
• Avoid delivery fees and wait times

Useful tips:

• Call ahead or place your order online (if available at that location) during peak hours like Friday night.
• Ask how long the current wait is, especially if you’re driving from Intown to a northern suburb—traffic can shift your timing.

Delivery

Many Johnny’s locations in metro Atlanta offer delivery either:

• Directly through the restaurant, and/or
• Through common third-party delivery apps

Delivery can be especially helpful if you’re:

• Staying at an Atlanta-area hotel without a car
• Hosting a small gathering or movie night
• Working late at an office in Perimeter, Cumberland, or suburban business parks

Always confirm:

• Delivery radius (some suburban locations deliver surprisingly far, others are more limited)
• Estimated delivery time during busy evenings or major sports events

Parking, Traffic, and Timing in Atlanta

Because Johnny’s locations are spread across metro Atlanta, your parking and timing experience can vary.

Parking

Most suburban Johnny’s around Atlanta are in shopping centers with free parking lots, which is convenient if:

• You’re coming with kids
• You’re picking up multiple pizzas
• You don’t want to deal with street parking or garages

If you visit a location closer to Decatur or step-inside-the-Perimeter, you may encounter:

• Smaller lots that fill during peak hours
• Shared parking with neighboring restaurants and shops

In that case, plan a few extra minutes to find a spot, especially on Friday and Saturday nights.

Traffic & Peak Times

In Atlanta, commute and event traffic can affect your Johnny’s timing significantly:

• Weeknights 5–7 p.m. – Heavier traffic may delay you or your delivery.
• Friday nights – Busy across most locations; expect longer wait times.
• Game days – When the Braves, Falcons, Hawks, or Atlanta United play, certain corridors (like I-75, I-85, and the Perimeter) see extra congestion, which can delay deliveries.

If you plan to feed a group at a specific time, you may want to:

• Place your order earlier than usual
• Ask for the store’s best estimate for pick-up or delivery
• Consider off-peak windows (e.g., late afternoon or early evening)

Family and Group-Friendly Features

Johnny’s New York Style Pizza tends to be popular with families, youth teams, and casual group meetups in metro Atlanta.

Many locations offer:

• Kid-friendly menu items – Cheese or pepperoni slices, simple pasta dishes.
• A casual atmosphere where kids don’t need to be overly quiet or dressed up.
• Large tables or the ability to push tables together for birthday gatherings or team celebrations (best to call ahead to reserve or notify them).

If you’re planning:

• A post-game team dinner (e.g., after soccer in Roswell or baseball in Alpharetta)
• A small birthday party or group outing

You can usually:

1. Call the specific Johnny’s location ahead of time.
2. Ask about seating capacity, timing, and large-order options (e.g., multiple XL pizzas, big salad bowls, and pitchers of soft drinks).

Some locations may be able to accommodate semi-regular meetups (like clubs or neighborhood groups) on quieter nights—calling the manager is the best way to check.

Considerations for Dietary Needs and Preferences

If you’re in Atlanta and eating with people who have dietary preferences or restrictions, Johnny’s may be able to accommodate some, but options vary by store:

• Vegetarian – Most locations can easily do cheese pizza, veggie pizzas, and salads.
• Gluten-sensitive – Some stores offer a gluten-sensitive crust or smaller gluten-friendly options.
• Dairy-free / vegan – You may be able to order pizza without cheese and load up on veggie toppings, but availability of vegan cheese or specialty items is location-dependent.

Because ingredients and procedures are not identical everywhere, anyone with serious allergies or strict needs should:

• Call the individual Johnny’s before ordering.
• Ask about cross-contact (for example, shared ovens or prep surfaces).

This is especially important if you’re picking up food for a group in Atlanta and need to ensure everyone can eat safely.

How Johnny’s Fits Into Atlanta’s Pizza Scene

Atlanta’s pizza scene is diverse, with:

• Neapolitan-style spots in areas like Inman Park and West Midtown
• Chicago- or Detroit-style pizza options scattered around the city
• Longstanding local pizzerias and newer craft-focused shops

Johnny’s New York Style Pizza holds a place as a familiar, accessible option for:

• Suburban families who want a consistent, casual pizza night
• Office managers ordering lunch for teams outside the core city
• Visitors staying in North Atlanta suburbs who want something simple and recognizable after a day of driving or work

If you’re staying in central Atlanta but willing to drive or get delivery from the suburbs, Johnny’s can serve as a straightforward “we know what we’ll get” choice—especially when feeding groups with different tastes.

Practical Tips for Atlantans and Visitors

To make your Johnny’s visit or order smoother in the Atlanta area:

• Check your nearest location first

  • Use a map app; pick the store with the best combination of distance, parking, and recent feedback.

• Call ahead during peak hours

  • For Friday evenings or game nights, ask about wait times for both dine-in and takeout.

• Ask about specials

  • Some Atlanta-area locations may offer lunch deals or family combos, especially on weekdays.

• Plan around Atlanta traffic

  • If you need pizza at a specific time, order earlier than you think you need, especially if you’ll be driving across I-285, GA-400, or I-75/I-85.

• Confirm group accommodations

  • For teams, clubs, or birthdays, talk to the manager about seating and large orders so you’re not scrambling when you arrive.

Johnny’s New York Style Pizza in and around Atlanta is designed to be predictable, comfortable, and easy to work into your daily routine—whether that means a quick slice at lunch, a family dinner after practice, or a stack of pizzas delivered for a watch party.