Your Pie in Atlanta: Where Custom Pizza Meets International Flavor

If you’re looking for build-your-own pizza with an international twist in Atlanta, Your Pie is one of the most recognizable fast-casual spots offering exactly that. It blends Italian-style, brick-oven pizza with a customizable, modern approach that fits the city’s mix of locals, students, families, and visitors.

This guide walks you through what to expect at Your Pie locations in and around Atlanta, how the menu works, common ordering tips, and how it fits into the broader international cuisine scene in the city.

What Is Your Pie and How Does It Work in Atlanta?

Your Pie is a fast-casual pizza restaurant where you:

1. Walk up to the counter
2. Choose a crust, sauce, cheese, and toppings
3. Watch your pizza assembled in front of you
4. Have it cooked in a hot, quick-fire oven (usually ready within minutes)

In Atlanta, the experience is geared toward people who want:

• Quick but sit-down-friendly meals
• Customizable options to match different tastes and diets
• A casual atmosphere where kids, groups, and solo diners all feel comfortable

While pizza is central, Your Pie often incorporates international influences—Italian-style crust and sauce, Mediterranean toppings like feta and olives, and sometimes more global flavors like buffalo sauce or barbecue, depending on the current menu.

Where You’ll Typically Find Your Pie Around Atlanta

Exact openings and closures can change, but Your Pie locations tend to show up in:

• Intown neighborhoods and near major streets
  Areas like Midtown, Downtown-adjacent corridors, and mixed-use developments near MARTA routes are common.

• College and university hubs
  Neighborhoods around Georgia Tech, Georgia State University, and Emory often attract fast-casual spots like Your Pie because of the steady flow of students and staff.

• Suburban shopping centers and mixed-use developments
  In the broader metro area, Your Pie locations frequently appear in open-air shopping plazas or newer live-work-play developments, where parking is accessible and walk-in traffic is high.

If you’re planning a visit, it’s a good idea to:

• Check hours, which can vary by location and day of the week
• Confirm whether a specific store offers delivery, curbside pickup, or only in-store ordering

What’s on the Menu: Pizza, Panini, Salads, and More

Build-Your-Own Pizza

The core of the Your Pie experience in Atlanta is custom pizza. Typically, you move through a few main choices:

1. Crust Options
Common options may include:

• Traditional hand-tossed
• Thin crust
• Sometimes gluten-friendly or cauliflower-style crust (availability can vary by location)

2. Sauce Choices

You’ll usually see several sauce bases, such as:

• Classic marinara (Italian-style red sauce)
• Olive oil and garlic (white base)
• BBQ or buffalo-style sauces at some locations
• Pesto-style sauce at select times or as part of specials

3. Cheeses

Typical cheese selections include:

• Mozzarella
• Feta
• Parmesan or Romano-style
• Sometimes dairy-free options, depending on the store

4. Toppings

Expect a mix of:

• Vegetables: mushrooms, spinach, onions, roasted red peppers, olives, tomatoes, jalapeños, etc.
• Proteins: pepperoni, Italian sausage, bacon, grilled chicken, and other meats depending on the location
• Finishing drizzles or garnishes: basil, balsamic glaze, or spicy oils at some stores

You can usually pick as many toppings as you like for a flat price or a tiered price structure, depending on the location’s current policy.

Signature Pizzas

For those who don’t want to build from scratch, Your Pie often offers preset signature pizzas, for example:

• Margherita-style (tomato, fresh mozzarella, basil)
• BBQ chicken-style combinations
• Veggie-focused options with lots of produce
• Meat-heavy combinations with sausage, pepperoni, and bacon

These preset pizzas are handy if you’re in a rush or trying the brand for the first time.

Panini, Salads, and Sides

Many Your Pie locations in Atlanta also serve:

• Panini: Pressed sandwiches using similar toppings and cheeses as the pizza menu
• Salads: Customizable or signature salads with Italian and Mediterranean flavors
• Side items: Cheese bread or similar shareable sides

These can be useful if someone in your group doesn’t feel like pizza.

Desserts and Drinks

Your Pie locations often include:

• Gelato: A nod to Italian dessert, with changing flavors
• Soft drinks and sometimes lemonade or tea options
• Select locations may offer beer and wine, particularly in intown or adult-focused areas, but this can vary widely.

How Your Pie Fits Atlanta’s International Cuisine Scene

Atlanta’s restaurant scene includes everything from traditional Southern cooking to global street food, and Your Pie fits in as a casual, Italian-inspired option with American-style customization.

Italian-Influenced, Atlanta-Style

Although Your Pie is not a fine-dining Italian restaurant, it draws on:

• Italian ingredients and styles (mozzarella, basil, brick-oven baking)
• Mediterranean elements like feta, olives, and olive oil bases
• American touches, such as BBQ pizzas or spicy toppings that reflect local tastes

For Atlanta residents and visitors, it can be a low-pressure way to enjoy Italian-style pizza with the flexibility to add your own twist.

Eating With Different Diets and Preferences

Your Pie locations often appeal to mixed groups because of the ability to choose every element.

Vegetarian and Vegan-Friendly Options

You can usually assemble a fully vegetarian pizza easily by:

• Choosing a veggie-heavy topping mix
• Skipping meat entirely
• Adding extra cheese or sticking with simple Margherita-style builds

For vegan eaters, options vary more by location. Some stores may offer:

• Cheese-free pizzas with olive oil or marinara sauce and veggies
• Occasionally plant-based cheese or protein alternatives, but it’s best to check with the specific Atlanta-area location you’re visiting.

Gluten and Allergen Considerations

Many Your Pie locations provide a gluten-friendly crust option. However:

• Preparation areas are typically shared, so cross-contact is possible.
• If you have celiac disease or a severe allergy, it’s important to speak directly with staff about preparation steps and risk levels.

Your Pie is generally comfortable with customizing for preferences, but each location may have slightly different ingredients or procedures, so asking questions at the counter is helpful.

Typical Price Range and What to Expect

Your Pie falls into the mid-range fast-casual price category in Atlanta:

• Personal pizzas are usually priced to be competitive with other build-your-own pizza and fast-casual chains.
• Add-ons like gelato, side salads, and drinks increase the total cost but can still be reasonable for a casual meal.

Factors that can affect what you pay:

• Choice of specialty crusts (e.g., gluten-friendly or cauliflower often cost more)
• Premium toppings, if any, at that location
• Location-specific pricing in higher-rent intown neighborhoods versus farther-out suburbs

Dine-In, Takeout, and Delivery in Atlanta

Dine-In

Most Atlanta-area Your Pie locations offer:

• Counter ordering, then table seating
• A casual, family-friendly setting
• Open layouts where you can watch pizzas going into the oven

They can work well for:

• Quick lunches from offices or campuses
• Casual dinners before events, movies, or games
• Group meetups where everyone wants something slightly different

Takeout and Curbside

Many locations support:

• Call-ahead or online ordering for pickup
• Takeout boxes that travel relatively well, especially for shorter distances in the city
• Some may offer curbside pickup, particularly in shopping center locations where traffic flow allows it

Delivery

Your Pie locations often partner with third-party delivery services in Atlanta. Availability can depend on:

• Your exact neighborhood or ZIP code
• Time of day and driver coverage
• The specific policies of the location you’re trying to order from

If you’re staying in a hotel or short-term rental, checking which location delivers to your address can save time.

When Your Pie Works Well for Atlantans and Visitors

Your Pie can be a practical choice in several scenarios:

• Before or after events
  Grabbing pizza on the way to or from a game, concert, or show—especially if you’re near major venues or MARTA corridors.

• Group outings with mixed tastes
  Each person can design a pizza to fit their own preferences, which helps when some want classic Margherita and others want extra spice or meat.

• Family-friendly meals
  The build-your-own style can be fun for kids, and the quick service works for children who don’t want a long wait.

• Solo diners and students
  Personal-sized pizzas and casual seating make it easy to eat alone or between classes or work shifts.

Simple Summary: Key Things to Know About Your Pie in Atlanta

Practical Tips for Visiting Your Pie in Atlanta

• Check the specific location’s hours before you go, especially on weekends or holidays.
• If you have dietary restrictions, ask staff about ingredients and preparation; menus can vary slightly by store.
• For large groups or team outings, consider going slightly off-peak (early lunch or early dinner) to find seating more easily.
• If you’re staying in a hotel near Downtown, Midtown, or by a major campus, look up the nearest location and confirm whether they deliver or if it’s easier to walk or rideshare.

For Atlantans and visitors alike, Your Pie offers a flexible, international-influenced pizza experience that’s easy to fit into a busy day of work, school, or sightseeing around the city.