Southern Baked Pie Company in Atlanta: What to Know Before You Go

If you’re craving Southern-style pies in Atlanta, Southern Baked Pie Company is one of the spots locals often consider for a slice of classic comfort. This guide walks through what they offer, where you can find them around Atlanta, how ordering works, and what to expect when you visit.

What Is Southern Baked Pie Company?

Southern Baked Pie Company is a Southern-inspired bakery that focuses on scratch-made sweet and savory pies. The style leans into buttery crusts, rich fillings, and classic Southern flavors—think pecan, bourbon-chocolate, chicken pot pie, and seasonal fruit pies.

For Atlanta-area customers, it tends to fill a few specific needs:

• A place to pick up holiday pies without baking from scratch
• A go-to option for gifting, especially to hosts, coworkers, and out-of-town visitors
• A convenient choice for comfort-food meals (like savory pot pies) you can take home and reheat

You’ll find their pies in multiple sizes, from individual minis to full-sized pies that feed a family or small group.

Atlanta-Area Locations and Contact Details

Southern Baked Pie Company operates multiple locations around metro Atlanta. Exact offerings can vary by store, but all generally focus on pies and related baked goods.

Here are some commonly used locations for Atlanta-area customers:

Because hours and addresses can change, it’s wise to:

• ✅ Call ahead before visiting, especially near holidays
• ✅ Confirm store hours, same-day availability, and pick-up options

If you’re coming from outside the Perimeter (OTP), look for north metro locations that may be closer than driving into central Atlanta.

Types of Pies You’ll Commonly See

While the exact menu can vary by season and store, Atlanta customers typically encounter a mix of Southern classics, savory options, and specialty flavors.

Classic Southern Sweet Pies

You’re likely to see variations of:

• Pecan pie – A staple for many Thanksgiving and Christmas tables in Atlanta
• Chocolate or bourbon-chocolate pies – Rich, dense, and often requested for dinner parties
• Key lime or citrus pies – Popular during warmer months or as a lighter option after heavy Southern meals
• Fruit pies – Apple, cherry, or seasonal berry pies, especially in fall and summer

These are commonly sold as whole pies for gatherings and sometimes slices or mini pies for individual treats.

Savory Pies and Pot Pies

For many Atlanta residents, savory pies from Southern Baked Pie Company are a weeknight dinner shortcut. These may include:

• Chicken pot pie – A common comfort-food choice, especially on colder or rainy Atlanta days
• Beef or vegetable pot pies – Options may rotate or appear seasonally

Savory pies are often sold frozen or chilled so you can bake them at home, which works well if you’re commuting from Midtown or Buckhead and want a simple dinner.

When to Go: Busy Times vs. Quieter Windows

Traffic and timing matter in Atlanta, and that extends to planning a pie pickup.

Regular Weekdays

On a typical weekday, you may find:

• Mornings to early afternoon – Often less crowded, easier to browse
• Late afternoon – Can pick up as people stop by after work or school

If you’re ordering for same-day office events downtown or in Buckhead, calling earlier in the day usually makes things smoother.

Holidays and Special Occasions

Atlanta residents often rely on Southern Baked Pie Company for:

• Thanksgiving pies (pecan, pumpkin, apple, etc.)
• Christmas and other winter holidays
• Easter brunches
• Mother’s Day, showers, and small gatherings

During these peak periods:

• Pre-ordering is usually strongly recommended
• Certain popular flavors may sell out early
• Same-day walk-in availability can be limited

If you live inside the Perimeter, consider pre-order and quick in-and-out pickup to avoid extra time on the road.

How Ordering and Pickup Typically Work

Southern Baked Pie Company offers several ways to get your pies, which can be helpful depending on where you are in Atlanta and how much time you have.

1. Walk-In

You can usually walk into an Atlanta-area location and choose from what’s in the case. Good for:

• Last-minute dessert needs
• Trying a slice or mini pie before committing to a full pie
• Picking up a single savory pie for dinner

The tradeoff is that selection may be limited compared with pre-ordering, especially late in the day or near major holidays.

2. Call-Ahead or Online Ordering

Many Atlanta customers prefer to:

• Reserve whole pies in advance
• Order multiple pies for holiday tables or office events
• Confirm special flavors or seasonal items

This approach helps if you:

• Live farther out (e.g., in Decatur, Smyrna, or Roswell) and don’t want to risk a wasted drive
• Are ordering for a specific event date

3. Shipping and Gifting

For Atlanta locals with friends or family outside the city, Southern Baked Pie Company may offer shipping options for certain pies. This can be useful if you:

• Want to send a “taste of Atlanta” to someone elsewhere
• Need a gift that doesn’t require you to handle delivery yourself

Availability and shipping policies can change, so checking details before relying on shipping for a time-sensitive occasion is important.

Price Expectations and Portions

Exact prices can vary, but most Atlanta customers find:

• Whole pies are usually geared for small gatherings or families
• Mini pies are suited to individual servings or samplers
• Savory pies can stand in for a full meal for one or more people, depending on size

When planning for a gathering:

• A single whole pie often works for 6–8 modest slices
• For larger groups, people commonly order two or more pies with different flavors

If you’re hosting a group in Midtown, Buckhead, or the suburbs, it’s a good idea to ask staff how many people a given size realistically serves based on how generous you want the portions to be.

Dietary Considerations and Label Awareness

If you have dietary restrictions or preferences, it’s important to ask questions before you buy. In typical Atlanta-area bakery settings like this, pies often include:

• Dairy and butter in crusts and fillings
• Gluten in traditional crusts
• Eggs and nuts in many recipes (especially pecan and some specialty pies)

Common consumer practices that can help:

• 📝 Ask about major allergens (nuts, dairy, eggs, gluten) before ordering
• 🧾 Check any labels or ingredient lists if available
• 📞 Call ahead if you or a guest has a severe allergy or specific dietary need

Specialty or modified recipes may be limited or unavailable depending on the day and location, so it’s safer not to assume alternatives are always on hand.

Tips for Atlanta Locals and Visitors

If you’re planning a visit to Southern Baked Pie Company while in or around Atlanta, a few practical tips often make the experience easier:

• Plan around traffic:
  • If you’re crossing the city (e.g., from East Atlanta Village to Buckhead), aim for late morning or mid-afternoon to avoid peak congestion.
• Use refrigeration or a cooler:
  • In Atlanta’s heat and humidity—especially between April and October—don’t leave pies in a hot car for long. A small cooler or insulated bag helps if you have multiple errands.
• Call ahead for larger orders:
  • For office gatherings in Downtown, Midtown, or Perimeter Center, confirming quantity and pickup times can help avoid day-of issues.
• Think about storage and reheating:
  • Many customers in Atlanta keep savory pot pies on hand in the freezer as an easy dinner option.
  • Ask for reheating instructions when you pick up, especially for frozen or chilled items.

Is Southern Baked Pie Company a Good Fit for You in Atlanta?

Southern Baked Pie Company tends to work well for Atlantans who:

• Want classic Southern pies without baking from scratch
• Need a reliable dessert for gatherings, potlucks, or family dinners
• Like the idea of savory pot pies as an easy at-home meal
• Enjoy sharing local-style gifts with visitors or out-of-town friends

If you live in Atlanta or are visiting the city, it’s a practical option when you’re looking for Southern and soul food–inspired pies, especially around holidays and special occasions. Calling ahead, planning for traffic, and considering storage in Atlanta’s climate will help your visit go more smoothly.